
You get the feeling reading yesterday's (Saturday) sports sections that there are two types of people: those who watch football and understand it, and those who believe what the newspapers tell them (and even their own newspapers).
Into the second category falls Richard Williams at least for today, whose singularly uninformed piece in Saturday's Guardian was totally refuted by last night's match. And this is not just me taking the high road, as two weeks ago I made it clear that although Argentina were winning, there were not doing so with any coherent tactical plan.
Williams said the 'circus surrounding the Argentina coach masks his clever man-management' and that he was 'dominating the World Cup'. The 'method to his apparent madness has become apparent [sic] over the past three weeks "What Maradona did first when he took over," an Argentinian journalist said this week, "was to nominate the key man in his side. That was Mascherano. He actually said, "The Team will be Mascherano and 10 others." And when he selected the squad of 23 to go to South Africa, he divided it very clearly into two: there would be the 11 players of the side, plus 12 supporters.'
Given this apparent inflexibility to the Argentinian side, no wonder Maradona was shackled by his own rigid tactics. There can be no Plan B, and frankly to base a team of Argentina's calibre around Mascherano sounds laughable to me. As a United supporter, I have seen him have amazing games, dominating the midfield, and not allowing opposing players the time or space to fashion attacking chances, but in this World Cup the Liverpool player looked detached from both attack and defense, hopelessly stuck in the middle as Khedira, Schweinsteiger, Muller and Podolski tied him up in knots.
Bastian Scheweinsteiger will get the plaudits for his effort yesterday, but it was Stuttgart's Sami Khedira in the first half who was the stand out player for me.
'Basically just get the ball to Messi or Tevez or Higuan and watch them do something amazing and score,' is not coaching. Gabriel Heinze was having a shocker, and would have been Argentina's worst player, if their other fullback Nicholas Ottamendi. Could he have been substituted at half time and replaced by an older, wiser player, who would hopefully have plenty of experience, and could display a clear head in what was a fiery contest? Javier Zanetti anyone?
Higuain scored 29 goals for Real Madrid this season, but he looked woeful, getting caught offside most of the times the ball was played up to him, while Angel Di Maria's distribution was worse than Nani's before the Portuguese's recent renaissance. Could Diego Milito not have been put on in place of Higuain at half time, pushing Carlos Tevez wide? Tevez and Messi for all their skill, were far too easily muscled off the ball by the German defense, and every time looked up to the referee for amends. Physicality is part of the game whether they like it or not.
Maxi Rodriguez and Di Maria were passengers in the Argentina team when they did not have the ball, and it was oh-so-easy every time Jerome Boateng had the ball, to pass it infield to either Khedira or Schweinsteiger, who then would have the space and awareness to pick out a surging Ozil or Muller.
Despite four straight wins in the competition last night was conclusive proof that Maradona does not understand football enough, and that frankly he does not deserve the position he has inherited as an international coach. If it were a charity or exhibition match, the flair and talent of Messi and co. would shine through, but in these sorts of matches, the team with the most mettle usually win through. And that certainly was not a passive Argentinian side. It could have been 6-0 by the end.
True, the early goal was a perfect start for Germany, since it meant that the South American team had to push up to find an equaliser, allowing Germany to counter-attack, which they did with the same precision that had dumped England out last week. But Diego did nothing to nullify the German strengths, as if they did not matter, as if by seeing a few great darting runs by Messi they would retreat into their shells and not dare attack for fear of conceding. It was an incredibly naive tactical set-up.
The only dampener for Sebastien Loew's Germany was the yellow card of Thomas Muller, ridiculously given for a deliberate handball when his arms were at his sides. As the smoke clears, it will be abundantly clear to everyone that Maradona's coaching ability is worth less than the ridiculous suit he wore pitch-side.
Props go to Arne Freidrich for his 'Klinsmann' celebration after Germany's third goal.